Which antique silver spoons are valuable?

Valuable antique silver spoons are generally defined by their age (pre-1700), the reputation of the silversmith, or a rare intended use. While common 19th-century teaspoons might only be worth their weight in silver, specific collector’s items can fetch thousands of dollars.¹

Here is a breakdown of what makes an antique silver spoon valuable.

1. High-Value Styles & Types

Some spoons were designed for very specific tasks that are no longer common, making them highly collectible rarities.²

• Apostle Spoons: These feature a figure of an apostle on the handle.³ A full set of 13 (the 12 apostles plus Jesus) is the "holy grail" of spoon collecting. Even individual 16th or 17th-century examples can sell for over £1,000–£5,000.

• Mote Spoons: These have a pierced (slotted) bowl and a spiked handle used to clear tea leaves from a teapot spout.⁴ They are delicate, rare, and very popular with tea enthusiasts.

• Caddy Spoons: Used for measuring dry tea leaves. Because they were often "status symbols," they feature incredibly ornate designs (like shells or leaves).

• Basting Spoons: Also called "hash spoons," these are very large (often 12+ inches). Their size alone gives them high silver value, but early 18th-century "Canon-handled" versions are particularly prized.

2. Renowned Makers (Hallmarks)

If you see these marks on the back of a spoon, the value increases significantly regardless of the style:

• Hester Bateman: The most famous female English silversmith.⁵ Her work is known for "bright-cut" engraving and delicate beaded edges.

• Paul Storr: Known for the "Regency" style. His work is exceptionally heavy, high-quality, and often associated with royal or aristocratic commissions.

• Georg Jensen: A 20th-century Danish maker. While "vintage" rather than "antique," his "Acorn" or "Blossom" patterns are world-renowned and hold their value remarkably well.

3. Key Value Indicators

Factor	What to Look For	Value Impact
Material	Look for the "Lion Passant" (Sterling) or "925".	High (Silver-plated is worth very little)
Age	Spoons from the Georgian era (1714–1837) or earlier.	Significant
Origin	Rare provincial assay marks (e.g., Exeter, Newcastle, York, or Norwich).	High
Condition	Sharp details and "crisp" hallmarks.	Moderate
Provenance	Family crests or inscriptions from famous historical figures.	Variable

4. Warning: Silver vs. Silver Plate

Many "antique" spoons are actually EPNS (Electroplated Nickel Silver).

• How to tell: If the spoon has marks like "EP", "A1", or "BP", it is likely silver-plated.

• Value: These usually sell for $1–$5 at thrift stores, whereas a solid sterling silver spoon of the same size might be worth $50–$200 just for the metal content.